Irresponsible claims of products being ‘organic’ should be eliminated if the National Draft Policy for Organic Production is passed in Parliament next year. The Draft Policy is currently open to input from government departments and other stakeholders, and an ‘organic standard’ is being developed with the SA Bureau of Standards, reports the Sunday Times.
We have written previously about the false claims that restaurateur Giorgio Nava made about all the meat at Carne coming from his Karoo farm and being organic, and that there currently is no organic certification body in South Africa, leaving the consumer vulnerable to inappropriate claims. Nava has since removed these claims from his menu and website. Only the Consumer Protection Act and the Advertising Standards Authority currently protect consumers against false organic claims.
To obtain organic certification, farmers will have to be audited and certified annually, to vouch for the ‘integrity’ of the production process. For its health benefits alone, organic farming and its certification should be encouraged and supported, but it would appear that it is a bureaucratic process and an expensive exercise to obtain organic certification, costing up to R 20000 per year. Organic certification agencies will be set up to handle the certification.
To get around the expense of organic certification, smaller organic producers will seek to obtain group organic certification under one certificate, the proposed participatory guarantee system being in line with international practice. The ‘co-operative’ of organic farmers would need to introduce an internal quality management system on their farms, for such a system. Pick ‘n Pay and Woolworths use third-party certification agencies, applying international certification standards.
Organic food is healthier, in containing higher levels of anti-oxidants, Vitamins A and C, and unsaturated fats, says Professor Raymond Auerbach of the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University. “Organic agriculture offers a real alternative to the way that we produce our foods, the way we mitigate and adapt to climate change, and it is a more sustainable way of operation, because an organic farmer is not dependent on fossil-fuel inputs such as expensive fertilisers and pesticides”, Professor Auerbach said. He is hopeful that the new Draft Policy will see more organic farming training by the government.
Whilst more expensive, organic foods are increasingly purchased by health conscious, ethically concerned upper-end consumers, and the impending introduction of organic certification is welcomed.
Chris von Ulmenstein, Whale Cottage Portfolio: www.whalecottage.com Twitter:@WhaleCottage
20
3070
27k
20
Your article of 30 November 2011, which quotes me on healthy organic agriculture, is factually incorrect.
After correctly stating that South Africa does not yet have organic standards, and is developing an organic policy and organic standards, the article states that there is no organic certification body in South Africa, and that “organic certification agencies will be set up to handle the certification”. There are already at least two South African organic certification agencies, Afrisco (see http://www.afrisco.net) and the BioDynamic and Organic Certification Agency. Afrisco certifies to its own standard, which is very similar to the European standard, and BDOCA works closely with European certifiers. In addition, at least seven overseas certification bodies operate in South Africa, and we have now also established the South African Participatory Guarantee System Association to assist emerging organic farmers with low-cost ocal certification.
While the article is correct that there are producers fraudulently claiming that their produce is organic, the implication that no products are legitimately certified organic is incorrect. Woolworths and Pick n Pay may use dubious labels such as “Farming of the Future” which only they themselves define and monitor, but if they claim to be selling “certified organic products” the consumer can look carefully at the label to see who certified the products, and can check on the web which standards were used. Mostly, they will find that the European Union’s comprehensive and well-monitored standards form the basis of the certification claims, and that certification agencies will be prepared to verify whether the products have in fact passed their stringent quality management criteria.