Eat Out Top 30 Restaurant shortlist 2017 : a prediction!


Last week I wrote that Eat Out has announced that it is changing to a Top 30 Restaurant shortlist for its 2017 Awards. As is customary. I have tried to predict which top South African restaurants will make the Top 30 Restaurant shortlist, which should be announced by Eat Out shortly! I have struggled to find more than twenty worthy restaurants to make the Top 30  list!

The rules for the selection of the Top 30 restaurants, as well as the judging criteria, are summarized below:

Eat Out Restaurant Awards 2017 change yet again, as does its Awards ceremony!

My Top 30 Restaurant list prediction below is presented in no particular order. I have selected restaurants, without a motivation, many included against my better wishes, and only to try to get to the 30 restaurants that Eat Out might announce as its Top 30 restaurants:

JAN Restaurant – the rules do not preclude a Nice-based South African restaurant from being eligible

The Test Kitchen

La Colombe


The Shortmarket Club

The Pot Luck Club

Chef’s Warehouse Bree Street


Restaurant at Waterkloof 

Camphors at Vergelegen

Benguela on Main



Jordan restaurant

Restaurant Jardine

Villa 47 Locanda

Mulberry & Prince

Hartford House



Faber at Avondale


Pierneef à La Motte

De Grendel 

Boschendal Werf Restaurant 





DW Eleven-13

A number of restaurants are not eligible for the Top 10 Restaurant Awards due to Chef changes in the past twelve months: 

Grande Provence: Chef Darren Badenhorst has just left, to open his brand new Le Coin Français in Franschhoek (main photograph of North Coast langoustine, with Boerenkaas, risotto, and Snoek). Chef Guy Bennett has taken over as Executive Chef 

Delaire Graff: Chef Michael Deg left the main restaurant at the end of September. He has moved to Cavalli Estate.

The Stack: Chef Warwick King moved to Delaire Graff a few months ago. Chef Jason Kosmas is the new Head Chef.

The Kitchen at Maison: A Top 10 restaurant in 2016, but no longer eligible due to Chef Arno Janse van Rensburg leaving at the end of October, to open Janse & Co in Cape Town. His successor has not yet been announced. 

Rust en Vrede: Top 10 last achieved in 2015. Chef John Shuttleworth has left, to return to the U.K., and has been replaced by Head Chef Fabio Daniel. 

The following restaurants opened during the course of the last year, but did not meet the opening deadline of 1 November 2016, to be eligible for the Awards this year: Reuben’s Franschhoek, Thali, Chef’s Warehouse Beau Constantia, Luke Dale-Roberts x The Saxon, La Petite Colombe (taking the space of the former Tasting Room at Le Quartier Français), Tintswalo, and La Tête. 

POSTSCRIPT 18/10: Last night Eat Out revealed its Western Cape Eat Out Best Everyday Eateries winners, impacting on our Top 30 finer dining Restaurant shortlist above. 

#  De Grendel was named a runner up in the Best Country Style restaurant category, so will not be named a Top 30 restaurant

#.  Chef’s Warehouse & Canteen won Best Tapas restaurant, and therefore will not make the Top 30 Restaurant list. 

#   Karoux did not win in any of the Award categories, strengthening our prediction of it being included in the Top 30 Restaurant list!

POSTSCRIPT 19/10: Eat Out has announced that it will only announce its Top 30 finalist restaurant list in November. At the Awards event there will no longer be a sit down meal. Food will be served, perhaps in canapé style. The chefs preparing the food for the event have been announced as Margot Janse, Chris Erasmus of Foliage, Scot Kirton of La Colombe, and Michelle Theron of Pierneef à La Motte.

Chris von Ulmenstein, WhaleTales Blog: Twitter: @Ulmenstein Facebook: Chris von Ulmenstein Instagram:@chris_ulmenstein


Please follow and like us:
Tweet 27k

WhaleTales Blog


We don’t spam!

Read our privacy policy for more info.

2 replies on “Eat Out Top 30 Restaurant shortlist 2017 : a prediction!”

  1. I’m not sure I would add Hartford House to the list – I haven’t had a good meal there since Jackie Cameron left – the Chefs Table in Umhlanga is more of a possibility.

  2. I have been there once a year, for the past three years, and have found it to be one of our country’s Best,.

Comments are closed.