Panel selects wines for wine lists of the new Cowboys & Cooks Group restaurants via blind tasting!


For the past two days I have participated in a Blind Tasting of more than 130 white, Rosé, and red wines at the offices of sponsorship specialists Divine Intervention, to select wines which will be incorporated into the winelists for the four restaurant brands of the new Cowboys & Cooks restaurant group, which has been founded by highly respected  restaurateur Michael Townsend and his strong support team.

Divine Intervention communicated with wine estates, briefing them on the new restaurant brands and their food offering, inviting them to submit wines. More than 1000 submissions were received, which were reduced for tasting to just over 200 bottles, of which we will be completing the tasting of top-end wines next week. 

On the panel with me was Stuart Bailey, CEO of Cowboys & Cooks, restaurateur and club owner Ian McMahon, restaurateur Greg Bax, Constantia Nek owner Alex Müller, Divine Intervention owner Shaun Terry, and myself. We were provided with scoring sheets, for wines tasted per cultivar, within various price bands. Six wines at most were tasted at a time, each scored between 0 and 5, the bottles being covered with a sock to hide the identity of the wine brand, and numbered between 1 and 6. Our glasses were numbered too. Our scores were read to tasting administrator Claire Robertson, who averaged them across all the tasters, and the score ranking was shared by Claire, whereafter Shaun identified each of the six wines, and revealed the price of each wine. Only the top three ranked wine brands per group of six tasted will be considered for the wine lists. 

On Monday we began the tasting with 6 Proseccos and Brut MCCs, followed by 22 Sauvignon Blanc wines, 14 Chenin Blancs (a category which I personally found to be very disappointing), 3 Unwooded Chardonnays, 7 Chardonnays, 6 White Blends, and five other white cultivars. Some of the top scoring wines included Le Delizia Prosecco, Graham Beck Brut, Zevenwacht, Spier, Edgbaston, Lourensford, Warwick The First Lady, Marklew, Shannon, Constantia Royale (a wine brand I had not heard of previously), Doran Vineyards, Lanzerac, Glenelly, Journey’s End, Flagstone, Rascallion (with an interesting vinyl-inspired label design), and Idiom. 

Yesterday we tasted 6 Rosé MCCs, 13 Rosés (a category felt to be disappointing), 7 Pinotages (I declared that this cultivar is not to my taste), 8 Merlots, 5 Shiraz, only 3 Cabernet Sauvignons, 13 Red Blends, and two other red cultivars. Stuart organised fillet and rump steak with chips, and mushroom and black pepper sauces to be delivered, for the tasting of the more full-bodied red wines. Better scoring wines were Kleine Zalze Brut Rosé, Graham Beck, Saronsberg (such a stylish label), Rosendal Wines Noble Nomad ‘He was my Lover’ (what a name for a wine!), Beyerskloof, Holden Manz, Flagstone, Spier, Lourensford, Hermanuspietersfontein, Warwick, Lanzerac, Glenelly, Journey’s End, Gouws & Co, Zevenwacht, Doran Vineyards, and Idiom.

The Cowboys & Cooks restaurant group consists of the following restaurant brands:

#. Cowboys & Cooks will open two branches, in Ocean Square in Sunset Beach, and in Rheede Street, off Kloof Street. It will become a meat eatery, with a Gentleman’s Club feel and interior design.(photograph below right)

#.  Cabron is a Tex Mex restaurant, the Bree Street branch open already, and further branches planned for Durbanville and Harfield Village. (Photograph bottom right)

#.  The Backyard BBQ is a ‘Lo and Slow’ Kitchen smoking diner, with branches planned for Rheede Street, the V&A Waterfront, and Stellenbosch. (Meat styles photograph left)

#.  Slug & Lettuce is a Gastro Pub, with existing branches in Long Street, Newlands, the River Club, Century City, Paarl, and Durbanville. 

Cowboys & Cooks, Cape Town. Cell 072 118 0531

Divine Intervention, Cape Town. Tel 082 416-4106. Instagram: @divine_intervention

Chris von Ulmenstein, WhaleTales Blog: Tel +27 082 55 11 323 Twitter:@Ulmenstein Facebook: Chris von Ulmenstein Instagram: @Chris_Ulmenstein


Please follow and like us:
Tweet 27k

WhaleTales Blog


We don’t spam!

Read our privacy policy for more info.